Is Google ready to replace Teachers?

Father Daughter using Google
Father Daughter using Google

Photo Credit: tsand via Compfight cc

When writing my previous two blogs (which can be found here and here), I entered the research phase with my mind already made up. I read the articles and watched the videos, picked out the facts that coincided most with my way line of thinking and proceeded to write my article. However for today’s post, I still don’t know whether I agree or disagree with the assertion that anything that can be googled should not be taught. I believe a large credit for this self-doubt comes from the excellent job of the debaters, who combined insightful debates with intriguing readings. So the purpose of this blog post is my journey to reach a conclusion, and you the reader? You’re welcome to come along for the ride.

When faced with a question I’m unsure about, I turned to the experts. The first article I read was by Terry Heick, who lays some of the blame on the teachers. He states that Google “creates the illusion that answers are always within reach even when they’re not. In fact, if users can Google answers to the questions they’re given, they’re likely terrible questions.” This line of teacher questions was absolutely the way schools have operated in the recent past and some continue to up to this day. However, if students today are presented with an assignment that can be quickly completed through Google, they are most likely to take that path. Although, that path is not without its pitfalls, as the following article states. It argues that “Google has become our external hard drive” and references a study that college students remembered less information when they thought they could easily access it later. At this point, I believe that we as teachers need to change the types of questions we are asking. We have to accept the fact that asking students to read their textbooks to find the start of World War II is nonsensical when they can find the answer in 1.5 seconds on their phones. We need to progress more into a critical type of thinking.

If the argument is that we need to move past questions that students can google, to a more critical and creative level of thinking, then we need to define what exactly is the critical thinking we are looking for? Here are some examples from teachers. Kim Devaney states that critical thinking is “being able and willing to examine all sides of an issue or topic… exploring the consequences or effects of any decision or action it is possible to take.” Another interesting take comes from Malinda McCuiston who states that “critical thinking is wondering about that which is not obvious, questioning in a precise manner to find the essence of truth and evaluating with an open mind.” I believe that statement encapsulates perfectly where we need to get to as teachers. We need to develop questions that cannot be answered in Google. We need to allow students to use Google to learn the basic facts of a situation and then present them with a scenario where they can combine these facts with their own base of knowledge and their learned perspective from the teacher. Because if we are to continue teaching simplistic lessons and assignments that can be completed using a device without any critical thinking, then the job of the teacher is essentially obsolete. So we as teachers must adapt in order to survive.

The final aspect we need to discuss is the role of memorization in the classroom. For some, this has become a dirty word that is unnecessary in the technological “Google” world. However, there certainly some facts to consider when discussing the efficacy of memorization. As Ben Johnson states, “the brain is a learning tool. This might seem obvious, but the brain is not a passive sponge. It requires active effort to retain information in short-term memory and even more effort to get it into long-term memory.” As well, he states, “the total emphasis on critical thinking has it all wrong: Before students can think critically, they need to have something to think about in their brains.” These are both important points and speak to the basis of learning as a whole. Johnson believes, and I agree as well, that learning is a process oriented exercise where the journey is more important than the destination. In order to have our students appreciate learning, they need to have opportunities to work at it. They must be pushed to achieve excellence outside of their comfort zone, rather than just relying on their phone to give the answers to them. My final points come from Dr. William Klemm who states that “The Internet is flooded with error, propaganda, and un-vetted assertions” and “Memorization provides exercise for the mind.” Both of these excellent points must be considered when discussing whether or not students should be made to memorize concepts. Students need to learn that not everything that they Google will be correct, and that the Internet is filled with more incorrect information than good. As well, he speaks about the need to provide practice for your brain. I am reminded of a story that I was told by Kelsie Lenihan’s husband, Nathan Birrell (a colleague of mine at LeBoldus). When working with math formulas with his grade 9 class, they inevitably asked him, “When will we use this in real life?” His response was simple and effective. He asked if there were any athletes or dancers in the class. After the students raised their hands, he asked them when they are training for their activities, why do they do jumping jacks or push-ups? After all, they don’t use those motions when playing their sport/dance. They responded that those activities trained their bodies and he interjected to say this is exactly what they were doing with the math formulas. The math formulas were a training for their mind. And this is where I will end, technology allows us to reach unprecedented levels in our classrooms, yet we cannot forget that we also need to train those minds to receive the information. We must push our students out of their comfort zones in order for them to appreciate the wealth of knowledge at their fingertips.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

24 thoughts on “Is Google ready to replace Teachers?

  1. That is a fantastic analogy!! I will definitely be stealing that in the future. I think you hit the nail right on the head when you said we need to train our brains to think and use the information we already have to go beyond the simple answers and explore deeper, more complex solutions. Thanks for sharing!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Great quote about training their minds (ex. jumping jacks for training) – too many kids need to know why are we doing this and we as teachers need to be able to explain why – just stating “its in the curriculum, that’s why” – is not a great answer. I think many teachers need to think of this before we teach things – if we cannot explain why we are teaching this, we best find out.

    Like

  3. I also love that analogy Kyle! I also tell my students that there is a lot of things I’ve learned that I don’t use in my job, but yet they’ve simply enriched my life. Understanding how things work is generally enjoyable! I always show the John Green Ted Talk that I posted in the google+ community to my students, and John talks about how everything we learn just opens up new possibilities for us to explore. We might really be interested in Location D, but you only find Location D if you first discover Location A, then B, then C, and then D all of a sudden becomes a possibility.

    Like

  4. As a visual learner, I also loved your analogy. Sometimes I get stuck on the spot when kids ask “why do we need to learn this”. It’s common sense to us, but to give them a specific reason, your analogy can forever be inserted here as the answer. Well said! Thanks for a great blog post this week!

    Like

  5. I’ll right ɑway grasp your rss as I can not to find yyouг e-mail
    subscription hhyρerlink or e-newsletter service. Do yοu have any?
    Kindly let me knokw in order that Ⅰ may subscribᥱ.
    Thanks.

    Like

  6. This latency won’t enable the concrete flooring acid stain to penetrate as is needed to offer a phenomenal concrete acid stain application so we have to use a floor
    maintainer (buffer) with a black or inexperienced scrub pad
    and TSP (trisodium phosphate) or our favourite, Super Blue ,
    to clean and store vac the floor clean.

    Like

    1. Hi, thank you for this post. The only concern I got is that when I am using posh-git () (which is amazing poselwhelr-git integration) it doesn’t work. SO it works fro git-bash, but doesn’t from posh-git =(

      Like

    1. mówi:o kurcze! podejrzewalam, ze to bedzie wiele godzin ale ta cyfra mnie powalila… Przeczytalam jakis czas temu, ze srednio aby zostac ekspertem w danej dziedzinie potrzebne jest 10 lat intensywnej pracy i skupienia tylko na tym 1 zandinu…aie ma co tylko do roboty:)Kamila, dzieki za slajdy! Daja do myslenia.ciao, Iza

      Like

  7. wo#;8#230&that&w8217;s something I’m dealing with right now, only I WANT the playdates! Play dates can be scary at first when I over-think things (like fitting in, etc.) I feel some of those fears now even as I’m looking for those social opportunities for my kids, but yet I know we need them for that social outlet. Thanks for posting this.

    Like

  8. voie de son maitreM. Gollnish a parfaitement raison et que tu ne sois pas d’accord ne change rien à l&s;auoraffqire.Aucune culture, aucune culture historique, aucun argument qui « tienne la route », toujours la m^me histoire avec la majorité des contributeurs à ce blogue.

    Like

  9. I hope srk signs a decent historical now so that his fans can come up with something susbatntial to compete against the MASTERPIECE that JA is.As of now,contest is totally one-sided!

    Like

  10. I was wondering if you ever thought of changing the layout of
    your site? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say.

    But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it
    better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having one or two pictures.
    Maybe you could space it out better?wholesale nfl jerseys

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s